Should your knees go over your toes?

Leslie Guerin • June 13, 2025

Debunking a Common Cue in Pilates, Barre, and Beyond

There are a handful of phrases that get repeated in almost every group fitness setting—cues so common we stop questioning them. Among them:

“Don’t let your knees go over your toes!”

For many students, this cue gets embedded so deeply that it echoes in their minds long after class is over. So when someone finds themselves in a raised-heel parallel squat, and their knees do move past their toes, they instinctively wonder: Am I doing something wrong?

The short answer is no—you’re probably not.

But the full answer is more nuanced, and understanding it will not only ease your mind, but also help you teach or train more intelligently.

Where Did the “No Knees Over Toes” Rule Come From?

To understand this cue, we need to look back at its origins. Like many fitness “rules,” this one likely came from a good place: injury prevention.

The idea was that if you keep your knees stacked directly over your ankles during movement, particularly squats or lunges, you reduce shearing forces on the knee joint and keep weight distributed in the hips and heels—where it’s safer.

It was also about ankle stability. When the shin moves forward too much, the ankle must dorsiflex (flex), and that requires mobility and control. For people with very limited or unstable ankle mobility—due to injury, genetics, or structural issues—this could cause pain or strain.

So yes, at one point, “don’t let your knees go over your toes” was a protective cue—but it was never meant to be universal. Like so many well-meaning one-size-fits-all rules, it’s been over-applied, over-simplified, and now it's time to revisit it.

Anatomy Check: What Actually Happens When Your Knees Go Over Your Toes?

Let’s look at some biomechanics.

When you bend your knees—especially in a squat or lunge—your center of gravity shifts. In order to stay balanced, something has to move forward to counterbalance the hips going back. Often, it’s the knees.

If you try to keep your knees behind your toes no matter what, you're likely to do one of two things:

  1. Overarch your low back by tilting your pelvis aggressively.
  2. Pitch your torso way forward, placing more strain on the back and decreasing glute/quad activation.

Neither of these are ideal.

Also, unless you have short femurs, super-mobile ankles, and perfect alignment, forcing your knees to stay behind your toes in every squat or bend just isn't realistic—or healthy.

So what's the more helpful mindset?

Focus on where the load is going—not just the joint alignment.
If your weight is centered in your muscles, and you're moving with control, it’s often perfectly safe for your knees to pass your toes.

Raised Heel Parallel: A Special Case

Now let’s apply this to a specific position in Barre and Pilates: raised heel parallel squats (aka relevé V or parallel chair with heels lifted).

In this stance, your feet are together (or hip-width), your heels are lifted, and you bend your knees to lower into a squat-like shape.

And guess what?
Your knees will go over your toes. They should.

Here’s why:

✅ Your Center of Mass Has Shifted

Lifting the heels reduces the base of support. In order to stay balanced, the knees must move forward to counterbalance the hips and maintain a vertical spine. If you tried to force the knees behind the toes in this shape, you’d fall over—or compress your low back trying to compensate.

✅ The Heels-Up Position Protects the Knees (and Challenges the Calves)

With heels lifted, your calves, hamstrings, and glutes are forced to fire up. You’re not resting into the joint. You’re building endurance and strength in the lower leg and hip muscles.

When executed with muscular engagement, this position places the effort in the muscles—not the joints—which is the goal.

✅ It’s a Closed-Chain, Controlled Environment

Unlike a jumping or landing movement, the raised heel squat is a closed-chain, slow-motion exercise. There’s minimal momentum and plenty of alignment feedback. That means less risk of joint overload and more opportunity for correction and control.

When Should You Be Cautious About Knees Over Toes?

Of course, there are scenarios where alignment does matter more:

  • In deep lunges, especially when the back knee is down, it’s helpful to stack the front knee over the ankle to avoid over-stretching or over-loading.
  • During high-impact landings, like in jumping or plyometrics, poor tracking can increase injury risk, particularly to the ACL.
  • For clients with knee pain, arthritis, or ankle instability, modifications may be necessary. In those cases, shortening the range of motion or using props can help.

But again, the key issue isn’t whether the knee goes forward—it’s whether the movement is being controlled by muscles or dumped into passive structures.

Why We Love to “Stack the Joints” in Pilates and Yoga

Another layer of confusion comes from a popular cue:

"Stack your joints—ankle under knee, knee under hip."

This cue is common in yoga, Pilates, and barre because it teaches basic vertical alignment. It can be helpful in poses like Warrior II, Chair, or in tabletop position.

But let’s be clear: stacking the joints is not always the goal.
It’s a starting point—a guideline for building awareness, not a rigid rule.

The human body moves in spirals, diagonals, and arcs. Movement isn’t always symmetrical or stacked, and we shouldn’t expect it to be. Once stability and strength are built, we move beyond stacking to dynamic alignment—where we respond to gravity, balance, and the task at hand.

So, What’s the Verdict?

Can your knees go past your toes?

Yes—if:

  • Your ankles and calves are strong and mobile.
  • You’re controlling the movement through muscular engagement.
  • You’re using body awareness, not just mimicking a shape.
  • You’re working in a supported, safe environment, like Pilates or Barre.

And in raised-heel parallel exercises, especially in Barre, this is not only acceptable, it’s essential.

The key is to train from the muscles—not the joints.
If your quads, glutes, hamstrings, and calves are firing, your movement is probably strong and safe.

A Note to Teachers and Cue-Givers

If you're a teacher, this is a good moment to reflect on how we give cues.

It’s tempting to repeat “don’t let the knees go over the toes” because it sounds good and feels familiar. But we need to ask: is it true? Is it helpful? Is it always relevant?

Instead, try cues like:

  • “Keep the weight in your legs, not your joints.”
  • “Track your knees in line with your middle toes.”
  • “Lift from your thighs, not your low back.”
  • “If you feel it in your knees, adjust your depth or position.”

These types of cues empower students to feel their way through alignment, instead of following arbitrary rules.

In Summary

The old “don’t let your knees pass your toes” cue may have come from a place of caution, but it’s often overused and misunderstood. In many Pilates and Barre exercises, especially raised heel positions, the knees will and should move past the toes.

What matters more than knee position is:

  • Muscular engagement (are you working from strength?)
  • Joint control (are you moving with awareness?)
  • Proper modification (is this right for your body today?)

Pilates isn’t about mimicking shapes. It’s about functional strength, control, and balance. If your knees pass your toes and your muscles are doing their job, you're exactly where you should be.

Want to learn more about smart movement?
Join me in a BarSculpt class or teacher training. I offer accessible, anatomically-informed Pilates and Barre that meets your body where it is—and helps you train for where you want to go.

Visit BarSculpt.com for virtual classes, certifications, and continuing education. Questions? Email me anytime.


By Leslie Guerin September 17, 2025
Using the Pilates Reformer
By Leslie Guerin September 15, 2025
From Springs to Confidence
By Leslie Guerin September 9, 2025
Let’s be honest: we’ve all done it at some point. You’re rushing from home, work, or errands, and you head to a Pilates class without giving much thought to what you’re wearing underneath your workout clothes. You throw on leggings, a top, and—without hesitation—your regular bra. After all, it’s just Pilates mat. It’s not running or jumping. How much could it really matter? The answer: a lot. In fact, wearing a traditional bra to Pilates mat class is one of the most common and avoidable mistakes I see women make. It’s not just about fashion—it’s about biomechanics, spinal comfort, and setting yourself up for the best experience possible. What you wear directly affects how your body feels and functions in class. And while Pilates is all about building strength, mobility, and alignment, the wrong gear—especially the wrong bra—can sabotage your comfort, compromise your performance, and even contribute to back pain. Why the Regular Bra Doesn’t Work for Pilates A traditional bra is designed with one goal: to shape and support breasts under everyday clothing. Most are structured with: Rigid underwires that press against the ribcage. Narrow straps that dig into the shoulders. Hook closures that create pressure points along the spine. Materials meant for aesthetics, not breathability or movement. That’s fine when you’re sitting at a desk or going out for dinner. But once you lie down on a Pilates mat and start rolling, curling, flexing, and twisting, all of those design features work against you. Here’s why: Spinal Discomfort – Pilates mat work involves a lot of supine (lying on your back) positions. The hook-and-eye closure digs into your spine, making it impossible to fully relax into the mat. That constant pressure leads to tension and pain. Restricted Movement – Underwires and rigid fabrics restrict natural rib expansion. Pilates breathing is three-dimensional—it requires your ribs to expand outward and back into the mat. A stiff bra limits this, creating shallow breath and less effective core engagement. Strap Pressure – Narrow straps dig into your shoulders during roll-ups, teasers, or any exercise where arms are overhead. Over time, this creates tension in your neck and upper back, distracting you from the precision Pilates demands. Compromised Flow – Pilates is about finding flow and ease. If you’re constantly adjusting straps or wincing at a clasp digging into your back, you’re not flowing—you’re fidgeting. The Importance of Costume Choices in Pilates Joseph Pilates himself often referred to “contrology” as an art form, not just an exercise method. He cared about alignment, grace, and the whole-body experience. What you wear is part of that experience. Think of it as your “costume” for the role you’re playing in class: a student committed to moving with control, precision, and awareness. If your outfit is working against you—pinching, digging, or restricting—you’re not able to embody the method fully. When we talk about costume choices, we’re not talking about fashion statements or brand labels. We’re talking about gear that supports your physical comfort, safety, and performance . What to Wear Instead The good news? There are better options—gear that is designed for movement, breath, and spinal health. Sports Bras with Wide Bands Choose bras without clasps or underwires. Wide, flat bands distribute pressure evenly so there’s no digging when you lie on your back. Look for materials that are stretchy but supportive, allowing ribcage expansion. Straps that Support, Not Dig Racerback or cross-back straps often provide better distribution and freedom of movement. Adjustable but wide straps help customize fit without cutting into your shoulders. Seamless Designs A seamless sports bra reduces irritation from seams or hardware. The smooth surface also means less distraction when rolling or twisting. Breathable Fabrics Moisture-wicking fabrics keep you comfortable, especially in longer classes or when working deeply into your core. Breathability supports better skin comfort and prevents overheating. How the Right Gear Elevates Performance Some may wonder: “Isn’t Pilates gentle enough that it doesn’t matter?” Actually, it’s precisely because Pilates is subtle, precise, and deeply connected to body awareness that gear matters even more. When you’re wearing the right bra and clothing: You breathe better. Your ribs can expand, making core activation more effective. You move better. Nothing digs, pulls, or distracts you. You focus better. Your mind stays on alignment, not discomfort. You recover better. Less unnecessary tension means less strain post-class. Pilates is about efficiency. Every detail—your posture, your focus, your gear—affects how efficient your practice is. The Back Connection Why do I emphasize the back specifically? Because back pain is one of the most common reasons clients come to Pilates. When you wear a traditional bra in class, the hooks and underwires don’t just cause temporary discomfort—they can exacerbate chronic back tension. Imagine lying on a hard clasp for a 50-minute class: your muscles subtly guard and tighten around that pressure the entire time. That’s the opposite of what Pilates is meant to achieve. Pilates builds a strong, supported back by improving spinal mobility, core stability, and posture. Don’t undermine that by placing an uncomfortable piece of hardware directly under your spine. A Personal Note as a Teacher As someone who has been teaching Pilates and Barre for over 26 years, I’ve seen every wardrobe choice imaginable. I’ve seen clients show up in jeans, in slippery socks, in bras with enough underwire to set off airport security. And every single time, their experience was compromised—not because they lacked strength or effort, but because their clothing was working against them. When I suggest a gear change, it’s never about judgment. It’s about giving clients the best chance to feel what Pilates really offers. Once someone experiences the difference—lying comfortably on the mat, breathing freely, moving without distraction—they never go back. The Mental Shift: Valuing Your Practice Here’s the bigger picture: choosing the right gear isn’t just about avoiding pain. It’s about valuing your practice enough to set yourself up for success. You wouldn’t show up to a dance performance in stiff jeans. You wouldn’t run a marathon in flip-flops. And you shouldn’t come to Pilates mat in a regular bra. Your costume matters because your practice matters. Conclusion Pilates is about creating strength, balance, and freedom in the body. But to access all of that, your body needs the right environment—and yes, that includes your clothing. A regular bra has no place in Pilates mat class. It will hurt your back, restrict your breathing, and distract from the flow. Choosing the right sports bra, with the right fit and fabric, sets the stage for comfort, performance, and a pain-free practice. So next time you head to class, take a moment to think about your costume. Give your body the gift of comfort. Because in Pilates, as in life, the details matter. And when the details work for you, the whole experience transforms.
By Leslie Guerin September 8, 2025
Why language, adaptability, and a willingness to evolve matter just as much as the exercises themselves.
By Leslie Guerin September 5, 2025
What training a 75-year-old client taught me about humility, observation, and the power of not having all the answers
By Leslie Guerin September 3, 2025
Why pacing, pause, and rest are just as important for our clients—and ourselves—as the workout itself.
By Leslie Guerin September 2, 2025
How one lighthearted class conversation spiraled into an unforgettable client moment—and what it taught me about teaching.
By Leslie Guerin August 27, 2025
Why Pilates Mastery Begins With Precision, Patience, and the Springs
By Leslie Guerin August 26, 2025
How Online Fitness Instruction Expands Your Reach, Builds Community, and Creates Long-Term Value
By Leslie Guerin August 22, 2025
Neutral, Supported Natural, and Imprint in Pilates and Barre
Show More