Understanding SI Joint Pain

Leslie Guerin • April 30, 2025

How It Mimics, Differs from, and Interacts with Sciatica


Understanding SI Joint Pain:

Subtitle:
When the Pain Isn’t Just in Your Head—or Your Back: How to Tell If It’s Your SI Joint, Sciatica, or Something Else Entirely

If you’ve ever experienced lower back pain that radiates down your leg, you're likely familiar with the term sciatica. But what if the pain isn’t coming from a herniated disc or nerve compression at all? What if it’s your sacroiliac joint—the often-overlooked yet essential connection point between your spine and pelvis?

In this post, we’ll break down the mystery of SI joint dysfunction, why it often gets confused with sciatica, how to start telling the difference, and what gentle, Pilates-based strategies and stretches might help you manage symptoms or support recovery.



The SI Joint: What (and Where) It Is

The sacroiliac (SI) joint is where your sacrum (the base of your spine) meets your ilium (the large bones of the pelvis). There’s one joint on each side of the body. These joints don’t move much, but they absorb and transfer load between the upper body and legs.

When the SI joint becomes dysfunctional—either too tight, too loose, or inflamed—it can cause localized pain, stiffness, and even radiating discomfort that mimics other conditions.



My Experience Working with Clients (And My Own Body)

In 2020, I dealt with a herniated L5-S1 disc that brought on intense sciatic pain—shooting down my leg to my toes. It was sharp, deep, and persistent. But over the years, as I’ve worked with clients, I’ve seen many people describe a similar kind of pain that didn’t turn out to be sciatica.

Instead, it was SI joint dysfunction.

A major difference I’ve noticed in clients with SI joint pain: they often can’t tolerate pelvic tilting at all. Especially posterior tilts—that motion you make to “tuck” the tailbone—can be unbearable. Where a spinal or nerve-related issue might allow for small movement, SI joint pain can feel like a brick wall. They freeze, flinch, or breathe sharply when asked to tilt the pelvis in either direction.

That tells me something deeper is going on—and often points to the SI joint.



SI Joint Dysfunction vs. Sciatica: Spot the Differences

Although the symptoms can overlap, here are a few general differences:

Symptom

SI Joint Dysfunction

Sciatica

Pain location

One side of lower back, buttock, can radiate to thigh (rarely past the knee)

Radiates from low back/buttocks down the leg, often to foot

Pain type

Dull, sharp, or stabbing—worse when sitting, climbing stairs, or standing unevenly

Burning, shooting, electric shock-like down the leg

Movements that worsen it

Pelvic tilting, standing on one leg, twisting

Forward bending, coughing/sneezing, prolonged sitting

Relief found through

Neutral spine, gentle stabilization, bilateral exercises

Extension (Swan), decompression, nerve flossing

Leg numbness or tingling

Rare

Common

These distinctions aren’t foolproof, but they’re a place to start. Proper diagnosis is crucial. If you're unsure whether you're dealing with sciatica, SI joint pain, or another form of back pain, you need to ask good questions—and so does your healthcare provider.



What to Ask Your Doctor or Physical Therapist

Here are a few helpful questions to bring into your next appointment:

  • Can you help me determine if this is disc-related, SI joint-related, or muscular?
  • Does this pain refer down my leg because of nerve irritation, or from joint dysfunction?
  • Can you check for sacroiliac instability or inflammation?
  • Are any of my muscles (glutes, hip flexors, pelvic floor) underactive or overactive?
  • Could my leg length, gait, or previous injury be affecting my SI joint?
  • What types of movement should I avoid—or include?

A qualified PT (Physical Therapist) will know how to test for SI joint involvement—often through palpation, movement tests like the FABER test, and simple load-bearing challenges. Many clients experience great relief through physical therapy, especially when manual therapy is combined with targeted strengthening.



What Causes SI Joint Pain?

The causes of SI joint dysfunction are varied but often come down to imbalance or instability:

  • Pregnancy or postpartum changes (ligament laxity)
  • Uneven leg length
  • Prior trauma or falls
  • Repetitive one-sided activities (think golf, tennis)
  • Weak glutes and deep core
  • Prolonged sitting or standing

When the support structures (like the glutes, pelvic floor, and transverse abdominis) don’t do their job, the SI joint takes on too much responsibility—and eventually fights back.



The Pilates Connection

I’ve worked with dozens of clients with SI joint issues who found relief not from aggressive treatment but from returning to mindful movement. Pilates, with its focus on alignment, breath, and core engagement, offers a powerful way to gently stabilize and support the area without aggravation.

Unlike traditional “core” exercises like crunches or planks, Pilates starts with the basics: finding neutral spine, breathing into the back ribs, and activating deep stabilizers without compression.

It also emphasizes bilateral work—meaning using both sides of the body evenly—which helps reduce SI joint irritation that can result from asymmetrical training or habits (like always crossing one leg or standing with weight on one side).



A Gentle Routine for SI Joint Relief

The following is a sample of Pilates-based movements and stretches I’ve seen help clients manage SI joint pain over time. These are not one-size-fits-all, and you should always consult with your provider before beginning any new movement if you're in pain.

1. Find Neutral Spine

Lying down:

  • Knees bent, feet flat, arms long by your sides.
  • Align the hip bones (ASIS) and pubic bone in the same horizontal plane.
  • This is your "home base"—come back to it often.

Why it helps: Reduces pressure on the SI joint and gives the spine a balanced starting point.



2. Pelvic Clock (Without Tilting)

  • Imagine your pelvis as a clock face.
  • Gently “roll” awareness from 12 o’clock (navel) to 6 o’clock (pubic bone), and side to side (3 and 9).
  • DO NOT exaggerate or push into the tilt. Keep the motion subtle and mostly mental.

Why it helps: Encourages subtle proprioception without stressing the joint.



3. Modified Swan (Elbows Down)

  • Lie on your belly with elbows under shoulders, forearms flat.
  • Gently press into forearms to lift the chest a few inches without tensing glutes or lower back.
  • Keep pubic bone grounded, shoulders wide.

Why it helps: Promotes spinal extension without spinal compression or sacral shearing.



4. Bridge with a Ball or Ring

  • Lie on back, feet flat, knees bent.
  • Place a small Pilates ball or pillow between the knees.
  • Squeeze gently and lift hips to a small hover—no need for a full bridge.
  • Focus on engaging glutes and inner thighs equally.

Why it helps: Recruits pelvic floor and stabilizing muscles in a symmetrical way.



5. Figure Four Stretch (With Caution)

  • Cross one ankle over the opposite thigh and gently pull the thigh toward your chest.
  • Only go as far as feels neutral—stop if any pelvic tilting brings on pain.
  • Keep pelvis as level as possible.

Why it helps: Opens tight glutes and piriformis without excessive spinal or SI movement.



6. Side-Lying Leg Lifts

  • Lie on one side, hips stacked, legs straight.
  • Lift the top leg a few inches and lower slowly.
  • Keep waist long and avoid rolling the pelvis back.

Why it helps: Strengthens glute medius and outer hip—crucial for SI joint support.



The Green, Yellow, and Red Light System

As I shared in my sciatica blog post, I often use a traffic light system to guide pain management in movement:

  • Green Light = Feels good or neutral → Keep going
  • Yellow Light = Some discomfort → Move mindfully, proceed with caution
  • Red Light = Sharp pain, instability → Stop immediately and reassess

Your job isn’t to push through pain—it’s to listen, adapt, and build trust with your body over time.



Final Thoughts: You're Not Alone

SI joint pain can be deeply frustrating. It’s not always visible. It’s often misunderstood. And it can feel like there’s no clear path to healing. But the truth is: you are not alone, and there are steps you can take to support your body.

From thoughtful Pilates movements to working with a skilled PT, relief is possible, and more often than not, it comes from tuning in—not tuning out.

Start with what you can do today: find your neutral, breathe into your ribs, and support your spine from the center outward.


By Leslie Guerin October 3, 2025
Why Teaching Reformer Pilates Starts with Resistance
By Leslie Guerin September 17, 2025
Using the Pilates Reformer
By Leslie Guerin September 15, 2025
From Springs to Confidence
By Leslie Guerin September 9, 2025
Let’s be honest: we’ve all done it at some point. You’re rushing from home, work, or errands, and you head to a Pilates class without giving much thought to what you’re wearing underneath your workout clothes. You throw on leggings, a top, and—without hesitation—your regular bra. After all, it’s just Pilates mat. It’s not running or jumping. How much could it really matter? The answer: a lot. In fact, wearing a traditional bra to Pilates mat class is one of the most common and avoidable mistakes I see women make. It’s not just about fashion—it’s about biomechanics, spinal comfort, and setting yourself up for the best experience possible. What you wear directly affects how your body feels and functions in class. And while Pilates is all about building strength, mobility, and alignment, the wrong gear—especially the wrong bra—can sabotage your comfort, compromise your performance, and even contribute to back pain. Why the Regular Bra Doesn’t Work for Pilates A traditional bra is designed with one goal: to shape and support breasts under everyday clothing. Most are structured with: Rigid underwires that press against the ribcage. Narrow straps that dig into the shoulders. Hook closures that create pressure points along the spine. Materials meant for aesthetics, not breathability or movement. That’s fine when you’re sitting at a desk or going out for dinner. But once you lie down on a Pilates mat and start rolling, curling, flexing, and twisting, all of those design features work against you. Here’s why: Spinal Discomfort – Pilates mat work involves a lot of supine (lying on your back) positions. The hook-and-eye closure digs into your spine, making it impossible to fully relax into the mat. That constant pressure leads to tension and pain. Restricted Movement – Underwires and rigid fabrics restrict natural rib expansion. Pilates breathing is three-dimensional—it requires your ribs to expand outward and back into the mat. A stiff bra limits this, creating shallow breath and less effective core engagement. Strap Pressure – Narrow straps dig into your shoulders during roll-ups, teasers, or any exercise where arms are overhead. Over time, this creates tension in your neck and upper back, distracting you from the precision Pilates demands. Compromised Flow – Pilates is about finding flow and ease. If you’re constantly adjusting straps or wincing at a clasp digging into your back, you’re not flowing—you’re fidgeting. The Importance of Costume Choices in Pilates Joseph Pilates himself often referred to “contrology” as an art form, not just an exercise method. He cared about alignment, grace, and the whole-body experience. What you wear is part of that experience. Think of it as your “costume” for the role you’re playing in class: a student committed to moving with control, precision, and awareness. If your outfit is working against you—pinching, digging, or restricting—you’re not able to embody the method fully. When we talk about costume choices, we’re not talking about fashion statements or brand labels. We’re talking about gear that supports your physical comfort, safety, and performance . What to Wear Instead The good news? There are better options—gear that is designed for movement, breath, and spinal health. Sports Bras with Wide Bands Choose bras without clasps or underwires. Wide, flat bands distribute pressure evenly so there’s no digging when you lie on your back. Look for materials that are stretchy but supportive, allowing ribcage expansion. Straps that Support, Not Dig Racerback or cross-back straps often provide better distribution and freedom of movement. Adjustable but wide straps help customize fit without cutting into your shoulders. Seamless Designs A seamless sports bra reduces irritation from seams or hardware. The smooth surface also means less distraction when rolling or twisting. Breathable Fabrics Moisture-wicking fabrics keep you comfortable, especially in longer classes or when working deeply into your core. Breathability supports better skin comfort and prevents overheating. How the Right Gear Elevates Performance Some may wonder: “Isn’t Pilates gentle enough that it doesn’t matter?” Actually, it’s precisely because Pilates is subtle, precise, and deeply connected to body awareness that gear matters even more. When you’re wearing the right bra and clothing: You breathe better. Your ribs can expand, making core activation more effective. You move better. Nothing digs, pulls, or distracts you. You focus better. Your mind stays on alignment, not discomfort. You recover better. Less unnecessary tension means less strain post-class. Pilates is about efficiency. Every detail—your posture, your focus, your gear—affects how efficient your practice is. The Back Connection Why do I emphasize the back specifically? Because back pain is one of the most common reasons clients come to Pilates. When you wear a traditional bra in class, the hooks and underwires don’t just cause temporary discomfort—they can exacerbate chronic back tension. Imagine lying on a hard clasp for a 50-minute class: your muscles subtly guard and tighten around that pressure the entire time. That’s the opposite of what Pilates is meant to achieve. Pilates builds a strong, supported back by improving spinal mobility, core stability, and posture. Don’t undermine that by placing an uncomfortable piece of hardware directly under your spine. A Personal Note as a Teacher As someone who has been teaching Pilates and Barre for over 26 years, I’ve seen every wardrobe choice imaginable. I’ve seen clients show up in jeans, in slippery socks, in bras with enough underwire to set off airport security. And every single time, their experience was compromised—not because they lacked strength or effort, but because their clothing was working against them. When I suggest a gear change, it’s never about judgment. It’s about giving clients the best chance to feel what Pilates really offers. Once someone experiences the difference—lying comfortably on the mat, breathing freely, moving without distraction—they never go back. The Mental Shift: Valuing Your Practice Here’s the bigger picture: choosing the right gear isn’t just about avoiding pain. It’s about valuing your practice enough to set yourself up for success. You wouldn’t show up to a dance performance in stiff jeans. You wouldn’t run a marathon in flip-flops. And you shouldn’t come to Pilates mat in a regular bra. Your costume matters because your practice matters. Conclusion Pilates is about creating strength, balance, and freedom in the body. But to access all of that, your body needs the right environment—and yes, that includes your clothing. A regular bra has no place in Pilates mat class. It will hurt your back, restrict your breathing, and distract from the flow. Choosing the right sports bra, with the right fit and fabric, sets the stage for comfort, performance, and a pain-free practice. So next time you head to class, take a moment to think about your costume. Give your body the gift of comfort. Because in Pilates, as in life, the details matter. And when the details work for you, the whole experience transforms.
By Leslie Guerin September 8, 2025
Why language, adaptability, and a willingness to evolve matter just as much as the exercises themselves.
By Leslie Guerin September 5, 2025
What training a 75-year-old client taught me about humility, observation, and the power of not having all the answers
By Leslie Guerin September 3, 2025
Why pacing, pause, and rest are just as important for our clients—and ourselves—as the workout itself.
By Leslie Guerin September 2, 2025
How one lighthearted class conversation spiraled into an unforgettable client moment—and what it taught me about teaching.
By Leslie Guerin August 27, 2025
Why Pilates Mastery Begins With Precision, Patience, and the Springs
By Leslie Guerin August 26, 2025
How Online Fitness Instruction Expands Your Reach, Builds Community, and Creates Long-Term Value
Show More